Skip to content
    Back to InsightsAI & Technology

    ChatGPT Hallucinations as Defamation: Who Is Liable When AI Lies About You?

    Defamation Guard Editorial10 January 202611 min read
    Share:

    Large language models like ChatGPT, Google Gemini, and Meta's Llama are generating false statements about real people at an unprecedented scale. These "hallucinations" — confident-sounding but entirely fabricated outputs — can include false criminal records, invented misconduct, and fictional professional failures. When these outputs are published or relied upon, they can constitute defamation under UK law.

    What Are AI Hallucinations?

    AI hallucinations occur when a language model generates text that is factually incorrect but presented with apparent confidence. Unlike human lies, hallucinations are not intentional — they result from statistical pattern matching rather than factual understanding. Common defamatory hallucinations include:

    • Falsely stating that a person has been convicted of a crime
    • Inventing sexual harassment allegations against named individuals
    • Fabricating professional misconduct or regulatory sanctions
    • Attributing statements to people who never made them
    • Confusing individuals with others who share similar names

    Who Is Liable for AI-Generated Defamation?

    The question of liability for AI hallucinations is developing rapidly. Potential defendants include:

    • The AI developer — companies like OpenAI, Google, and Meta that create the models. Under section 1 of the Defamation Act 2013, the developer may be a "publisher" if the hallucination is generated and displayed to users
    • The platform operator — websites and apps that deploy AI chatbots may bear responsibility as secondary publishers
    • The user who republishes — anyone who copies AI-generated defamatory content and shares it (e.g., in a blog post, email, or social media) becomes a primary publisher
    • The employer — organisations that deploy AI tools for customer-facing communications may be vicariously liable for defamatory outputs

    The Section 5 Defence for Operators

    Need Specialist Legal Advice?

    Defamation Guard offers a free, confidential case assessment and can introduce you to an independent specialist defamation solicitor. Get clarity on your options today.

    Website operators that host AI-generated content may seek to rely on the section 5 defence for website operators. However, this defence requires the operator to demonstrate that it did not post the statement — which is problematic when the AI is the operator's own tool generating content in real-time.

    Proving Publication and Serious Harm

    AI hallucinations present unique challenges for the standard defamation elements:

    • Publication — each time a user receives a hallucinated defamatory response, this constitutes a separate publication. If millions of users can generate the same false output, the scale of publication may be enormous
    • Identification — the hallucination must identify the claimant. Full names, job titles, or contextual details that make the person identifiable are sufficient
    • Serious harm — harm may be inferred from the scale of potential publication and the gravity of the false allegation (e.g., fabricated criminal convictions)

    Practical Remedies

    1. Notice and takedown — notify the AI developer that their model generates defamatory content about you. Document the hallucination with screenshots and exact prompts
    2. Pre-action protocol — send a formal letter before action to the developer requiring model correction
    3. Injunctive relief — seek a court order requiring the developer to filter or correct the defamatory output
    4. Damages claim — pursue compensation for reputational harm, particularly where the hallucination has been widely reproduced
    5. Right to erasure — under UK GDPR, request deletion of inaccurate personal data from the model's training data
    Can I sue OpenAI if ChatGPT says false things about me?▼
    Potentially yes. If ChatGPT generates false and defamatory statements about you that are published to users, OpenAI may be liable as a publisher. The legal position is evolving, but several claims have already been brought internationally. UK law's lower threshold compared to US law makes claims more viable here.
    What if the AI just got my name confused with someone else?▼
    Name confusion is one of the most common forms of AI hallucination. If the AI attributes someone else's misconduct to you, this is defamatory regardless of whether the AI "intended" to refer to you. What matters is whether readers would understand the statement as referring to you.
    Is there a time limit for suing over AI hallucinations?▼
    The standard 1-year limitation period applies from the date of publication. However, each time a user generates the same hallucinated output, this may constitute a fresh publication. The single publication rule under section 8 of the Defamation Act 2013 may not apply straightforwardly to dynamically generated AI content.

    Free Confidential Case Assessment

    Has defamation caused you harm?

    • No-obligation free case assessment
    • UK's 1-year limitation period — act now
    • Referral to specialist defamation solicitors
    Share:

    Disclaimer

    This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and you should seek professional legal advice for your specific situation. Defamation Guard is an information and referral service, not a law firm, and can introduce you to an independent specialist solicitor.

    Pre-Action Letter Checklist

    Download our free checklist covering everything you need before sending a pre-action defamation letter.

    Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Need to speak to a specialist?

    If you're dealing with a defamation matter, Defamation Guard offers a free case assessment and, if appropriate, can introduce you to an independent specialist defamation solicitor for tailored legal advice.