Skip to content
    Back to InsightsCase Law

    The Repetition Rule in UK Defamation: Lessons from Monir v Wood

    Defamation Guard Editorial22 May 202510 min read
    Share:

    The repetition rule is one of the most important principles in UK defamation law. It prevents defendants from defending a defamatory statement by showing someone else said it first. Monir v Wood [2018] EWHC 3525 (QB) provides a modern illustration.

    What Is the Repetition Rule?

    Established in Shah v Standard Chartered Bank [1999] QB 241, the rule provides that repeating a defamatory allegation makes you liable as if you made it yourself. You cannot say "I was only reporting what X told me." To rely on the truth defence, you must prove the underlying allegation is true — not merely that the rumour exists.

    The Facts of Monir v Wood

    The defendant published statements repeating allegations made by others about a property developer's business practices. When sued, Wood argued he was merely reporting what others had said. The Court rejected this, applying the repetition rule — Wood had republished the allegations as his own and was liable.

    How the Rule Works in Practice

    • Reporting allegations: "A told me that B is a fraudster" makes you liable for alleging B is a fraudster. To rely on truth, you must prove B is a fraudster
    • Social media sharing: Retweeting or sharing a defamatory post makes you liable. This applies to all platforms
    • Journalism: Journalists cannot escape liability by attributing to sources. They need truth or public interest
    • Qualifying phrases don't help: "Allegedly," "reportedly," "I've been told" do not provide protection

    Need Specialist Legal Advice?

    Defamation Guard offers a free, confidential case assessment and can introduce you to an independent specialist defamation solicitor. Get clarity on your options today.

    Exceptions and Nuances

    • Neutral reportage: Balanced reporting of a public dispute may be protected if the journalist doesn't adopt either side's allegations
    • [Qualified privilege](/blog/qualified-privilege-defence-uk): Fair and accurate reports of court proceedings and parliamentary debates are protected
    • [Absolute privilege](/blog/absolute-privilege-defamation-uk): Statements in parliamentary or judicial proceedings are completely protected
    • The meaning matters: If the reasonable reader would understand the statement as merely reporting that an allegation was made (not endorsing it), the defamatory sting may differ

    The Repetition Rule Online

    The rule has particular significance in the digital age. Every share of a defamatory post is a fresh publication — the sharer cannot defend by saying "I didn't write it." This applies to:

    • Retweeting defamatory posts on X (Twitter)
    • Sharing defamatory Facebook posts or Instagram stories
    • Forwarding defamatory WhatsApp messages
    • Creating TikTok duets or stitches with defamatory videos

    Practical Implications

    1. Think before sharing: Before retweeting content with serious allegations, consider whether you could defend a defamation claim
    2. Attribution is not a defence: "According to sources" or "it is alleged" does not protect you
    3. Claimants can choose targets: If an allegation has been widely repeated, the claimant can strategically choose which republisher to sue
    4. Seek advice before reporting allegations: Legal advice can help you discuss others' allegations without personal liability

    Related reading: Defamation Act 2013 explained | Social media liability | Honest opinion defence

    Free Confidential Case Assessment

    Has defamation caused you harm?

    • No-obligation free case assessment
    • UK's 1-year limitation period — act now
    • Referral to specialist defamation solicitors
    Share:

    Disclaimer

    This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. Every case is different, and you should seek professional legal advice for your specific situation. Defamation Guard is an information and referral service, not a law firm, and can introduce you to an independent specialist solicitor.

    Pre-Action Letter Checklist

    Download our free checklist covering everything you need before sending a pre-action defamation letter.

    Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

    Need to speak to a specialist?

    If you're dealing with a defamation matter, Defamation Guard offers a free case assessment and, if appropriate, can introduce you to an independent specialist defamation solicitor for tailored legal advice.